What is a good rental yield? 2026 benchmarks, the gross-vs-net trap, and the financed test that actually decides

Here's the short answer, because the question deserves one: in most 2026 US markets, a gross rental yield of 8-12% — roughly $667 to $1,000 of monthly rent per $100,000 of purchase price — is the zone where a leveraged long-term rental starts to pencil. Net of operating expenses, that band works out to about a 4.5-6.5% net yield. Below 7% gross, a financed property almost never carries its own mortgage; above 13-14%, the market is usually paying you to absorb risk the yield number can't see.

The long answer is that no single yield number is “good” on its own — because the same 10% quote can describe a deal that cash flows and a deal that bleeds $100 a month, depending on what sits underneath it. This post defines gross and net yield, works both on a real $220,000 example, gives you benchmark ranges by market type, and then runs the financed test — the step that actually decides whether a yield is good for you.

Rental yield, defined (and the vocabulary trap)

Gross rental yield is annual rent divided by purchase price:

Net rental yield subtracts operating expenses — vacancy, property taxes, insurance, maintenance, management, capital reserves — from rent before dividing. Everything except the mortgage comes out. If that sounds familiar, it should: net yield is what US investors call the cap rate. The “yield” vocabulary is more common in UK, Australian, and international listings, which is exactly why it trips people up: a British listing quoting “7% yield” and a US broker quoting “7% cap” are describing very different properties. The gap between gross and net is typically 40-50% of the number, so the first question to ask about any quoted yield is always gross or net?

One more translation: gross yield is the reciprocal of the gross rent multiplier, and it's the same screen as the 1% rule wearing different clothes. A 12% gross yield is a GRM of 8.3 is “1% of price in monthly rent.” If you already think in those terms, nothing here is new — the full three-way conversion between yield, GRM, and cap rate has its own post.

Both yields on a real deal

Take a $220,000 single-family renting for $1,850 a month — $22,200 a year. The gross yield takes five seconds:

• Gross yield: $22,200 ÷ $220,000 = 10.1% (a GRM of 9.9 — about 0.84% of price in monthly rent)

The net yield takes an expense budget. Underwrite it line by line: 5% vacancy ($1,110), property taxes at 1.4% of value ($3,080), insurance ($1,400), 8% maintenance ($1,776), 8% management ($1,776), and 5% capital reserves ($1,110). Total operating expenses: $10,252 — a 46.2% expense ratio, right in the neighborhood the 50% rule predicts. That leaves net operating income of $22,200 − $10,252 = $11,948, and a net yield of:

• Net yield: $11,948 ÷ $220,000 = 5.4%

Same house, same day: a 10.1% quote and a 5.4% quote. Neither is wrong — but only one of them knows the property has a roof, a tax bill, and occasional empty months. (Run your own line items in the NOI calculator if you want to stress the expense budget.)

Benchmarks: what yields look like by market type

Rental yield is mostly a function of the rent-to-price ratio of the metro you're shopping, which is why national averages are useless. Here's the honest 2026 map, with the net-yield equivalent at a typical mid-40s expense ratio:

Two readings of that table matter more than the numbers themselves. First, yield and appreciation trade off. A $500,000 house renting for $2,100 a month is a 5% gross yield — deeply cash-flow-negative when financed at 2026 rates — and the people buying it know that. They're underwriting equity growth, not income, which is a legitimate strategy with its own math (cash flow vs appreciation works that comparison). A yield benchmark only applies if income is the goal.

Second, the top of the yield table is not free money. A 16% gross yield on an $80,000 house is the market pricing in older mechanicals, tougher tenant pools, thinner exit liquidity, and expense ratios that routinely blow past 50% — the same forces that killed the 2% rule as a national screen. High yield is compensation, not charity.

The financed test: where “good” actually gets decided

Here's the part most yield explainers skip. Yield — gross or net — is an unlevered, property-level number. It has no idea your mortgage exists. But almost every individual investor buys with debt, so whether a yield is good depends on whether it clears your financing. Run our $220,000 house through a standard 2026 deal structure: 25% down ($55,000) and a 30-year loan at 7% on the remaining $165,000.

• Annual debt service: $1,098/month ×12 = $13,172
• NOI: $11,948
• Cash flow: $11,948 − $13,172 = −$1,224/year (about −$102/month)
• DSCR: $11,948 ÷ $13,172 = 0.91

A 10.1% gross yield — comfortably inside the “good” band — loses money every month at 25% down and 7%. The DSCR of 0.91 also means most investment-property lenders wouldn't write the loan as-is: they want NOI to cover debt service by 1.20-1.25×. Work the algebra backwards (fixed costs stay fixed; the percentage expenses scale with rent) and this house needs roughly $1,990/month of rent — a 10.8% gross yield — just to break even, and about $2,360/month — a 12.9% gross yield — to hit DSCR 1.25. Check any deal's coverage in the DSCR calculator; the levers that move the bar are down payment, rate, and the expense ratio, and small changes in any of them swing the answer.

That's the honest resolution of the headline question. The 8-12% band is where deals start to pencil — where the financed math becomes winnable. Whether a specific deal inside that band actually wins depends on its tax county, its insurance premium, your rate, and your down payment. The cash flow calculator runs the whole stack — rent to NOI to debt service to monthly cash flow — in about a minute.

Why two identical yields aren't identical

One last failure mode before the checklist. Gross yield treats every rent dollar as equal, but operating costs vary wildly between properties with the same rent-to-price ratio. Our example house pays $3,080 a year in property tax; its twin across a county line might pay $6,500. Same 10.1% gross yield — but the twin's NOI drops to about $8,500, its net yield to 3.9%, and its financed cash flow from −$102 to roughly −$390 a month. Taxes are the cleanest example; flood-zone insurance, a 30-year-old roof, and self-managed pro formas that omit management do the same damage. The yield gets you to the front door. The expense budget decides what's behind it.

How to actually use rental yield

1. Screen with gross yield — ruthlessly

Yield's real job is triage. Price and asking rent are the only two numbers you have for forty listings at once, and gross yield ranks them in seconds. Set your line — in most financed scenarios that's somewhere around 8-10% gross — and cut everything below it without guilt. A 6% gross property is not going to underwrite its way into cash flow at 2026 rates.

2. Underwrite survivors with net yield (cap rate)

For anything that passes the screen, build the expense budget line by line and compute the real NOI. This is where the twin-property gaps surface, where pro-forma fantasy vacancy gets corrected, and where a cap rate you'd actually defend gets built.

3. Decide with the levered numbers

Run your actual financing and read cash flow, cash-on-cash return, and DSCR. That's the tier of metrics that knows what you paid and what you borrowed — and it's the only tier that can tell you whether this yield, on this house, with this loan, is good.

FAQ